

I don’t know that OP is wrong per-se, but I think they’re overstated a bit.
Their statement that passkeys are better than people using the same password, but are a step back for people using a password manager, is maybe a bit much. It’s basically the same, but sometimes better.
Most of their drawbacks are the hardware implementations, but that’s already true of people using hardware 2FA, and corporate management, which is already a problem if you use Apple’s or Google’s existing baked-in password managers.
But if you don’t already have both of those problems, the standard is basically just “instead of having the password manager pretend to type in a box, what if they dumped something into the stream directly”, and that extends to what if the UI didn’t ask for anything and just said “hey, do you want to login? Just let me know and it’s done”
And, like, should you be able to export from Apple’s built in store to migrate? Absolutely, but if you never used Apple’s passkeys in the first place, because ugh gross, then it’s not a problem you need solved yet.
There is one problem I’ll admit, which is that it’s easier to make a sketchy password manager that just pretends to be a keyboard. I myself don’t actually use passkeys because I sync my passwords with git and use pass, which is cool and I love it. And then I type them using a dmenu script and xdotool, which is silly and I love it. But that doesn’t work with passkeys which I can definitely store in git, but would require a real actual connection between my browser and the tool, in a way that I don’t think currently exists.
But just because I can’t use my sketchy crap, doesn’t always mean it’s a step back 😛



I have a specifically not NSFW one, but it feels relevant anyway. My wife was about to get ready for work, and while I can’t remember exactly what lead to it, there was some kind of “betcha can’t catch me” chase from the kitchen to the bedroom that was not sexual in nature, that’s just where her work clothes were. Well, to punctuate her victory she leaps onto the bed for a diving finish, including a rotation so she’d come down on her back like a high-jump. Majestic.
Well, it would have been, if she’d not overshot a bit and smashed the back of her head off the edge of the headboard… Hard.
We go to the hospital because she’s got a concussion, and when they ask how this happened, and you answer that she whacked her head really hard against a headboard, it opens up a whole new category of questions! The kind that involve me being asked to leave the room so we could answer the questions separately, just in case she had a different answer when I’m not present in the room with her… 😅
The concussion was bad enough she needed a bunch of time off work, so naturally friends and family are concerned and have questions! Questions like “oh wow, that sounds pretty bad, how did it happen?”. And, like, it’s pretty hard to give an answer of “she banged her head really hard on the headboard with me before work” without people getting really squinty and blushy 😛
So it’s not sexual! Honest! It just really really sounds like it…