His argument was literally that
- artists, writers, and programmers are “labor aristocracy” and deserve no respect because they’re sitting around making art and writing code while other people are toiling and laboring,
- genAI is a “free resource” (“it’s free for me to use at work”) that “helps everyone make things” instead of having to rely on skill and expertise and therefore makes everything equal,
- it’s hypocritical of people to be worried about the environmental and societal impact of genAI because “only white people are worried about it now that their hobbies are being threatened and everyone else is catching up”.
Pointing out there there are artists and programmers from every race and economic class, as well as perfectly ordinary people in every walk of life who are all actively being harmed both by the theft of ideas and labor and by the physical effects of gigantic data centers ruining communities, was met with much hand-waving and incredibly impenetrable philosophical jargon.
I’m particularly incensed because I’m as leftist and anticapitalist as they come and this felt like the fuckery some conservative cockwomble would try to come up with to parody socialism, except this guy was completely serious.
That’s the typical AI user mentality. Just laugh and point as this is about the extent of what they deserve.
Nothing like arguing socialism and imperialism with people who don’t know what either of those words mean.
AI is built on the unprecedented theft and exploitation of the intellectual labor of the creative working class by greedy capitalists.
Literally the definition of stealing the surplus value
I’ve talked with someone that argued that the concept of intellectual property is inherently capitalist, and therefore it taking the art and other works of people doesn’t matter in the grand scheme.
And I guess I see the point. I don’t agree with it, but I can’t argue that well against it.
This is like saying we don’t need to pay a minimum wage now because under communism each will be provided according to their needs.
IP is a necessary evil under the current system to stop distributors like Instagram, tiktok, or AI companies from taking labor from workers (artists, writers, etc.) without compensation.
That is true… but it’s important to remember, I think, that even under a non-capitalist system, people are still going to care about plagiarism and attribution. Recognizing where an idea came from is a basic sign of respect for the effort that goes into creating them, you know?
IP is a necessary evil under the current system to stop distributors like Instagram, tiktok, or AI companies from taking labor from workers (artists, writers, etc.) without compensation.
Seemingly this did not work.
Almost like rules dont apply for the ruling class and the whole IP spiel is just, as pointed out, completely and utterly capitalist.
And to think that IP laws would prevent the rich from thieving is hilariously naive.
You’re not really a communist if you don’t think the rich can ever be brought to heel.
Of course they can be brought to heel. But not really with laws of the bourgeois state.
Then you bring them to heel to respect IP.
They dont even pay taxes. IP is FOR THEM and is used against US.
They can only be forced to adhere to laws by constant fear of execution otherwise they “invent” a legal loophole.
It’s also saying that artists’ works shouldn’t be considered personal property. Even as an anarchist, I wouldn’t want people taking my drawings and using them however they wanted without my blessing.
That is logical equivalent to saying that because property is a capitalist concept theft is a form of socialism.
So the robber barons are actually socialists too, and wage theft isn’t theft because money shouldn’t exist, and if you can steal candy from a baby that’s ok because ownership doesn’t exist and only the strong survive. Delusional people can justify anything.
It’s pretty twisted, especially when you consider the players involved, as well as who is being exploited, and who is benefitting from AI the most.
Even the top brass within Microsoft are quoted as having said that what they’re doing is the “largest theft of labor in history”, and I tend to agree.
After all, the richest men on Earth are getting richer at the expense of the artist, the thinker, the writer and all forms of intellectual and physical labor. Profit may be theft, but theft is also still theft.
Capitalists always frame socialist programs as theft so… it actually lines up.
If AI really was a free resource, then maybe that part almost makes sense. It’s losing billions per quarter, it’s not free.
“helps everyone make things” instead of having to rely on skill and expertise and therefore makes everything equal,
everyone else is catching up”.
In both of these statements it sounds like they’re saying, “the AI is smarter than me, and I’m stupid without it.”
The open models in good inference engines can be dirt cheap, but that’s not a good argument because (among other reasons) it’s not the bulk of what is used.
Honestly any company that uses AI as part of their business model should be running open-weight models locally. They can be fine-tuned to their specific use case, it’s not as compute-intensive as the initial pre-training.
And overall it’ll save the business money because they don’t have to shell out for these flagship APIs that are only going to crank up their rates as they become more desperate to prove to investors that they can turn a profit.
Individuals who use it should be running something between 7 to 24 billion parameters depending on how many resources they can allot to it. And even if you don’t use it, it can’t hurt to keep local copies of a few.
Well, yes, they should use open weight models.
…But on prem?
Honestly, finetuning modern MoEs to actually improve at tasks (much less without overfitting) is very difficult. It’s why finetunes are so rare in HF now, even though we still some for Qwen 27B.
Even deploying such large models is hard.
That, and inference costs decrease at scale (to a certain point). It’s way cheaper for some inference company to keep dozens of servers saturated, with parallel requests split across many clients, than for a company to leave a bunch of mostly-idle servers barely spun up.
In privacy insensitive scenarios, open weight APIs make sense for most companies (IMO), and the great thing about that is you can pick from hundreds of providers. Rates are highly competitive. You aren’t locked to a single source like the “frontier” models.
Hey I can hack my smart TV with a Claude code subscription and get rid of all the ads and listening device shit so I’m not gonna hate. Ai for the people, baby.
AI…at least how it’s currently being deployed and marketed…is the ultimate expression of Capitalism. They are stealing the labor of others, and leasing it back to the public, for endless profit…all while destroying the environment and undermining the working class.
OP got trolled.
Ah yes, aristocracy. That’s why artists and writers are known for being loaded.
Debating with a conservative is like playing chess with a pigeon. They just knock over all the pieces, shit all over the board and strut around like they won.
That’s the thing! This guy actually is a very involved leftist, complete with theory and everything…and then he goes on to say this
They sound like a tankie. Tankies are leftists like Dr. Pepper is a medical doctor
I got the reference! Guessing you’re Canadian?
I wish!
People who argue in favor of AI art are, at best, talentless hacks.
LLMs take the intellectual labor of billions and convert it into a form that can be privatized and commodified so capitalists can charge for access. It’s the enclosure of the commons extended to the digital realm.
Universities have been doing this since forever.
Consider that generative AI is a “thing”. That thing can be sold as a product to accrue capital, but that thing can also be given away freely. A socialist government may redistribute land so that every citizen has a plot, but that doesn’t erase history or the fact that the land was originally stolen from native inhabitants when it was colonized.
Capitalism’s backbone is theft. The middle-class is having a hissy-fit now that the forces of capitalism are turning inwards. My critique of Shoshana Zuboff’s book on surveillance-capitalism has been that it’s not a new form of capitalism at all. It’s just capitalism. Only those mechanisms are now being turned towards a previously ‘protected’ class and they really don’t like it when the leopards eat their faces.
Why do people like pretending that no one has a problem with capitalism except militant communists? Even conservatives do but don’t realize/admit it. We all inherently feel how unfair capitalism is unless we have enough wealth to not have to work. Stop trying to divide people further and find better ways to spend your time.
I’ve been a software developer for a long time. If that asshole doesn’t think working 16-18 hour days for months on end while sleeping under my desk because I literally didn’t have the time to go home and come back constitutes hard work, well, he can fuck right off.
And lets be honest here, if they living in a socialist society, they’re probably the one that freeload off everyone’s hardwork.
Nah! You see, real workers break their backs at factories, lift weights, sweat, etc. You just sit at a computer and most of the time you don’t even type you just stare at the screen. That doesn’t even qualify as work!
/s obviously, but I’ve heard sincere variations of this and I’m sure you too.
Yeah, I’ve been told something along those lines often enough. Usually by people whom would be permanently broken in twain by three months of pre-E3 crunch time, never to recover.
Not that it’s particularly relevant since they wouldn’t be able to do the job in the first place. Then again, I freely admit that I’d make for one hell of a plumber, but not in a good way.
genAI is a “free resource” (“it’s free for me to use at work”)
i.e. literally not free, it’s capital the boss allows him to use while on the clock while he works for a wage.
Art is Imperialist.
- My ass it is. Giving any degree of power to the commoners, which is what art does, is anti-Imperialist if anything. If anything, AI, which is actively taking power away from the commoners, is the Imperialist thing.
The art that AI creates is imperialist through capitalism. The only people that use AI art are the ones trying to sell you something. Either it’s a view or a product. Most real artist understand that AI can’t create, it can only emulate.
Then film must be only emulation and never art, for every artist in a film production has been brought with capital and toils for capital’s sake. Yet the capitalist’s latest film is hailed as a groundbreaking art piece. Is it not only a prerecorded shadow of artists compelled to create under duress? Is it not just emulation? Every record held in high-esteem is a life-less recording that’s only ever brought to an emulated life via machines. Machines can not create art but art can be propagated to the proletariat by machines and rendered alive by way of emulation. Your record player will for a brief amount of time emulate Beethoven’s symphonies, but when it’s denied electricity it is nothing.
If art is intrinsically human and machine-art is nothing but hollow emulation can we not take these shadows and resemble them with that uniquely human quality: art. To create new art from the corpses of emulation.
A new breed of artist arises that specializes in machine ensembles. The pure artist can continue what they’ve always been doing. No one has told him to stop. His work will continue to be encouraged and all that is his legacy will subsumed into the collective whole that the proletariat can manipulate at will with generative AI.
So is mental gymnast a bourgeois or proletariat form of labor?
I can entertain a good faith argument that being able to make art while other toil is privilege.
There is no good faith argument that using the plagiarism machine is socialistic, or that it’s anything but privilege as well. You are making “art” while the actual artist toils at their craft
There is no good faith argument that using the plagiarism machine is socialistic
Nailed it.
It’s literally a bias distribution device, owned by the wealthiest capitalists to have ever walked the earth
GenAI is anathema to socialism
Exactly. Literally every AI person is so obviously manipulated into psychotic viewpoints that are anti human because of AI.
You’re wasting time arguing with a troll. Tell him AI is copypasta for lazy tryhards and offer to buy him a coloring book since it’s essentially the same time. You can even offer to hang the pictures on the refrigerator when he’s done coloring it if he stays inside the lines like a good boy.
(know what’s funny, no one ever colors in a coloring book and says look at this “art” I made. Children are smarter then AI bros.)















